Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: 24 Illegal Song Downloads Cost Us Woman 220,000 Dollars
Zymic Webmaster Forums > General Discussion > Chatter Box
Jack
Since I recently posted a file sharing news article the other day, it made sense to continue my theme and post this:

QUOTE
In the first US trial to challenge the illegal downloading of music on the Internet, a single mother from Minnesota was ordered Thursday to pay 220,000 dollars for sharing 24 songs online.

Jammie Thomas, 30, was the first among more than 26,000 people sued by the world's most powerful recording companies to refuse a settlement after being slapped with a lawsuit by the Recording Industry of America and six major music labels.

She turned down an offer to pay a few thousands dollars in fines and instead took the case to court.

Unlike some who insist on the right to share files over the Internet, Thomas says she was wrongfully targeted by SafeNet, a contractor employed by the recording industry to patrol the Internet for copyrighted material.

Her lawyer said earlier this week that she had racked up some 60,000 dollars in legal fees because she refused to be bullied.

And while Thomas insisted on the courthouse steps that she had never downloaded or uploaded music, her lawyer tried to convince jurors there was no way to prove who had uploaded songs on the Kazaa file sharing network.

A jury took just five hours to decide that evidence provided by the music labels showed otherwise and found Thomas guilty of copyright infringement, court records showed.

Thomas, an employee of the Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe, an Indian tribe, was ordered to pay a 9,250-dollar fine for each of 24 shared songs cited in the case, including Godsmack's "Spiral," Destiny's Child's "Bills, Bills, Bills" and Sara McLachlan's "Building a Mystery."

It could have been a lot worse.

The fine could have reached 150,000 dollars a song if the jury had found "willful" copyright infringement.

Had the record companies sued her for all 1,702 songs found in the online folder the fine could have run in the millions.


http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=07...;show_article=1
Jack
Well, perhaps she should of got fined a lot more... kazaa?!
Cmain
This is totally ridiculous.

Indie music ftw. smile.gif
MrCracker
Ouch.. theres a life long debt.
Ed
If she has that sort of money to pay legal bills then I'm sure she had the money to legally buy the cds.

Then again this is for the sharing.

EMOruffino
damn, im glad i dont get caught, thats why i use SoulSeek, its for INDIE bandz who dont give a sh*t
bezz
Why not sue her for $1,244,449,601 a song? That's the number of people who use the internet and have access to her music collection right? $9,250 is way too low. Maybe she should serve jail time as well. Stealing money from destiny's child may cause them to go bankrupt, which effects their livelihood. We wouldn't want destiny's child to not have enough money to put out another amazing album. I say we sentence anyone convicted of music piracy to death. The record industry needs our money to put out amazing new artists. Just look at how great the artists are in the billboard top 10. You can thank the record companies for these wonderful contributions to the world of music. We bow down to you Sony BMG, EMI, Universal, and Warner.
Mark
QUOTE(Jack @ Oct 5 2007, 10:50 AM) *
Well, perhaps she should of got fined a lot more... kazaa?!

No she should have been fined $1 per song, not fucking $9,125!!! Or fine, $2 a song since she downloaded it and probably? uploaded it up once? *sigh* IP address != person
Jack
Some reasons for the fine: http://www.news.com/8301-13578_3-9791764-38.html
EMOruffino
its just crazy madness.... MADNESS I TELLS YOU!

What about the iTunes Wi-Fi store? Im sure some ppl can hack it so they can bluetooth others songs.. lol
Colin
Stupid Woman...Lol I think it would have been funny if theyed have charged for all the music
Nexus
The RIAA can go to hell, as far as I'm concerned. Good thing I don't upload songs heh.

Of course it's still illegal to download songs as well.

Remember - it's only a crime if you get caught LOL. And don't take that as me endorsing crimes...
Azzakio
ohmy.gif lol thats my illegal music site out the window... new ideas......


"my illegal music site" Thats a joke, dont sue me !!!
Dwayne
QUOTE(bezz @ Oct 6 2007, 04:08 AM) *
Why not sue her for $1,244,449,601 a song? That's the number of people who use the internet and have access to her music collection right? $9,250 is way too low. Maybe she should serve jail time as well. Stealing money from destiny's child may cause them to go bankrupt, which effects their livelihood. We wouldn't want destiny's child to not have enough money to put out another amazing album. I say we sentence anyone convicted of music piracy to death. The record industry needs our money to put out amazing new artists. Just look at how great the artists are in the billboard top 10. You can thank the record companies for these wonderful contributions to the world of music. We bow down to you Sony BMG, EMI, Universal, and Warner.


I hate you.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.